Latest Diablo 3 News
DiabloWiki Updates
Support the site! Become a Diablo: IncGamers PAL - Remove ads and more!

Best Of Forum Mafia WIFOA Game Thread

Discussion in 'Diablo 2 Community Forum' started by Goryani, May 27, 2013. | Replies: 1225 | Views: 35341

  1. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    This is a game of Mafia. For those unfamiliar with Mafia, here is a basic description. Source .


    Forum rules apply while playing in this game.

    Votes

    • Everyone has a single vote. The vote format is: Vote: Name. Bolded. With colon. With a name.
    • Simple spelling issues in the name are acceptable.
    • You may only have one vote at a time.
    • You may change your vote during the day. In order to change your vote, you must first unvote any current vote and then vote for a different player. Format: Unvote: Name. The name is also required.

    Lynches

    • One player may be lynched per day.
    • A player receiving more than half of the votes will be considered locked and will be lynched at the end of the day.
    • If no player receives enough votes to be lynched by the end of the day, no one is lynched.

    Communication

    • No one is allowed to post during the night.
    • No one is allowed to talk about this game outside of this thread unless your role specifically tells you otherwise.
    • No one is allowed to post after they die.


    PMs

    • The first rule of forum mafia is that you don’t talk about PMs.
    • The second rule of forum mafia is that you don’t talk about PMs.
    • If you have something to say or ask, then say it or ask it without referring to PMs.
    • Referring to information contained within a PM is OK. Quoting that information is not!
    • This also applies to any QuickTopic you participate in.

    Modkills

    • Violating any game rules may result in modkill.
    • If you are modkilled, you can’t win.
    • Intentionally modkilling yourself will result in some type of penalty placed on the rest of the members of your alignment. The penalty will depend on the severity of the infraction. This penalty may include: factional roll block, withholding information and giving the other side an extra night kill.

    Miscellaneous Rules

    • Do not edit your posts unless instructed to do so by the moderator.
    • Stay active. A minimum of two, contributive, non-consecutive posts are required per day phase.
    • A Temp Ban from the forums results in a modkill from the game.

    Exceptions

    • If your role conflicts with any of the game rules, follow the instructions on the role. The role supersedes game rules.
    • I may modify these rules at any time to create a better play experience.

    Questions, Feedback, Issues
    I welcome all questions and feedback. If you don’t want to post in the game thread, do so via PM or the e-mail address found in your initial alignment PM.

    If you see any mistakes or other issues, please bring them to my attention (publicly or privately) promptly.
    Last edited: May 27, 2013
  2. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    Game Specific Rules

    This is a Wine In Front Of All (WIFOA) style game similar to City Mafia and Night of the Living WIFOA. In a WIFOA game, all roles are bid upon by the players. To determine the bidding order, all players choose two numbers between 1 and 20. The first is the primary number, the second is only used for tiebreakers. The person who chose the lowest number will have first pick of roles, with subsequent people choosing as you go higher in the numbers. However, if any number is chosen by multiple people, then they will choose a role after all single number picks have chosen. In a nutshell, lower numbers are better, but singles will always beat out duplicates, which beat out triplicates, etc. If the tiebreaker numbers are equal as well, then time of submission is used as the final tie-breaker.

    Once all bids are submitted, the pick order list will be published and we can proceed into picking roles.

    [HR][/HR]
    Role List:

    1. Boromir (LoTR). Can blow his mighty horn during the day and disrupt all night talk meetings for that night. Boromir's Horn will last one good blow before cleaving. [Not in a Shawshank way...]

    2. Professor Farnsworth (All My Circuits). Inventor! Could invent one of three things each night and pass them around.

    • What If Machine - must be given to someone, one-shot role-blocking item, may be invented multiple times
    • Box to another Universe! - must be given to someone, one-shot bus driver item, may be invented multiple times
    • Dooms Day Device - can't give away, can't use until next day, target dies, along with everyone the target targeted/got targeted by (save for Farnsworth himself). may be invented a single time

    3. Fifth (Stargate). Human Form Replicator. X% chance to recruit non-mafia into your cult. Recruited players lose all abilities and traces of their former life. Only Fifth will know the exact value of X% (but it's not too different from the original role).
    This role replaces your alignment and has a Cult Win Condition: You win if your cult makes up over 50% of the remaining players.

    4. Parrot (And Now For Something Completely Different...). You may be blue, but you're definitely not Norwegian. Also, you're not dead, yet. You have the ability to mimic the first night action of other player. Each night, you may choose one player to parrot, and X players to target with your mimicked ability (X is chosen to match the other roles in the game).

    5. Adam Faulkner (Saw). Photographer. Each night you receive a picture from a randomly chosen action. During the day, you may choose to show it to everyone else.

    6. Papa Smurf (Press Your Luck). You have a post restriction: You must always talk like a smurf does.

    7. Henry Porter, Governor (Hellsmouth). You have one opportunity to block a lynch. However, you cannot block your own lynch.

    8. Forger (Ravenwood Retreat)

    • Framing - Targeted player, if investigated by rolecop this night, will show up as role X, the default is hitman but you chose X each night.
    • Tailor- You will show up as a redirector to rolecops. This can be changed to another role of your choosing..
    • Two Shot Redirection - Target player’s action will now target the player of your choice until the next night.

    9. Malcom Berrett (Stargate II). A Human. You own an Anti Replicator Gun. During the day, if you include the word “ARG†in one of your posts, and a replicator makes a post in the following 4 posts, it dies instantly. You can use it two times during the whole game.

    10. The Advisor (Half-Life). You are a terrifying psionic entity that in some odd way, can tap into the vast portal energy generated by the combine. Protect this technology for it can also be your undoing. You are bulletproof and lynchproof at the start of the game.

    11. Old Lady Mallard "Mother" (NCIS). Reads as anti-town to cop investigations. Will stab and wound anyone trying to enter her mansion except Ducky or Tony...as she believes he is there to move her furniture. Anyone stabbed by her goes to Bethesda Hospital for the day and cannot post for 24 hours time.

    12. Gray Man (Wheel of Time). Soulless: Your unique nature makes it hard for people to see you. You are unwatchable, untrackable and unfollowable.

    13. The Abominable Snow Monster of the North, aka Bumble (RRRR). You are a Strongman. Being a Strongman, if you perform a kill, you will bypass any doc, bodyguard, bulletproof, etc.

    14. Kotaro (Black Blood Brothers). Sage Blood - Sire (recruit) Immune.

    15. Darcy (Till Death...). Barkeep. During the day, you can choose 4 players. One of them is chosen randomly and you both can speak during the next night phase. No information about roles / alignment is revealed.

    16. Mystery Win Condition (City Mafia) - An alternate win condition. What is it? IT'S A MYSTERY. You'll know before game starts. The Mystery Win Condition will be a neutral/third-party win con able to share a win with town and mafia. This role replaces your assigned win condition.

    17. Rogue (Roles of Madness). Stealth is your key weapon. Each night you can either track a target or watch a target.

    18. Stan Marsh (South Park). One shot global role block.

    19. Cliff Clavin (Cheers/Frasier). Barfly. During a day phase you may pick one person. Actions affecting said person on that day phase or following night phase will be delayed until their next active phase (Lynches will not be affected). You will be seen targeting the affected postal recipient that night.

    20. Jack of All Trades (Night of the Living WIFOA) - Comes with following, all one-shots: Doctor, Cop, Coroner, Roleblocker.

    21. Athena (Greek Gods). Goddess of Wisdom. Namecop/Rolecop. Each night, you may choose to investigate a player to reveal their name and role.

    22. Melisandre (ASOIAF)

    • War Planning: Prevent the night kill of every living member of your House, one time use. (For town, House = yourself. For mafia, House = mafia faction)
    • Read the flames: Learn the abilities used by one player each night (follower)

    23. Julian "Bean" Delphiki (Ender's Game). Listener. You will receive one randomly chosen night chat message per night.

    24. Kangaxx (Baldur's Gate). JOAT Mage. You have the following 1 shot abilities:

    • Mirror Image - You cast three duplicate copies of yourself to confuse your foes. Any effect targeting you will have a 75% chance to fail for the duration of this spell.
    • Domination - Choose target player. That player cannot cast a vote for the duration of the next day phase.
    • Power Word, Kill - The pinnacle of the Dark Arts, uttering this spell instantly kills the target. Due to the demanding nature of this spell and your current weakened state, you may not vote during the following Day phase if you cast this spell.
    [HR][/HR]
    Pick Order List


    1. Malevolent 4 // 4
    2. djmbbandie 7 // 19
    3. Solar Ice 9 // 2
    4. pharphis 10 // 10
    5. Sathoris 11 // 1
    6. coju 17 // 20
    7. flubbucket 2 // 5
    8. Noammr 2 // 23
    9. Caluin Graye 3 // 1
    10. thefranklin 3 // 2
    11. Drixx 6 // 3
    12. Pyrotechnician 6 // 5
    13. kestegs 6 // 13
    14. Moar 5 // 8
    15. Bad Ash 5 // 18
    16. Gwaihir 5 // 1
    17. BipolarChemist 5 // 1
    18. Ankeli x // x
    19. Noodle x // x

    [HR][/HR]
    Time to send in your role picks. I hope it doesn't take as long as bids.

    Process

    1. Everyone sends in their pick at the same time. Send em!
    2. After picks are received...
    3. starting with picker #1
      • if their picked role is not taken, they get to play as that role.
      • if their picked role is already taken by someone with an earlier pick order, they get to play as a vanilla role (vanilla townie or vanilla goon, depending on alignment).
    4. repeat for picker #2
    5. then picker #3
    6. and so on
    Last edited: Jun 3, 2013
  3. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    Living Players (2)
    1.
    2
    3
    4
    5 djmbbandie
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10 Drixx
    11.
    12
    13
    14
    15
    16
    17
    18
    19

    Dead Players
    11 Sathoris - lynched D1 (Forger, Town)
    1 pharphis - died N1
    13 coju - lynched D2 (Vanilla, Town)
    2 Bad Ash - died N2
    12 Solar Ice - died N2
    16 Noodle (FoE) - lynched D3 (Vanilla, Mafia)
    15 Ankeli - modkilled D3 (Vanilla, Town)
    17 Malevolent - died N3
    19 Noammr - lynched D4 (Vanilla, Mafia)
    4 kestegs - lynched D5 (Vanilla, Town)
    14 Gwaihir - died N5
    6 flubbucket - lynched D6 (Bumble, Town)
    7 Pyrotechnician - died N6
    18 thefranklin - died N6
    9 Moar - lynched D7 (Cliff - Postman, Town)
    8 Caluin Graye - died N7
    3 BipolarChemist - lynched D8 (Vanilla, Mafia)
    Last edited: Jun 23, 2013
  4. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121

    The town has cleansed the streets of all scum and win the game!




    [HR][/HR]
    Day 1 Vote Count
    Caluin Graye (4) - coju, [STRIKE]Sathoris[/STRIKE], flubbucket, Noammr, Ankeli
    flubbucket (0) - [STRIKE]Noammr[/STRIKE],
    kestegs (0) - [STRIKE]Bad Ash[/STRIKE]
    Sathoris (11) - Solar Ice, Caluin Graye, thefranklin, Bad Ash, BipolarChemist, pharphis, Moar, Gwaihir, djmbbandie, kestegs, Drixx
    Solar Ice (0) - [STRIKE]thefranklin[/STRIKE], [STRIKE]Bad Ash[/STRIKE],
    djmbbandie (0) - [STRIKE]pharphis[/STRIKE], [STRIKE]Ankeli[/STRIKE],
    Drixx (3) - Sathoris, [STRIKE]kestegs[/STRIKE], [STRIKE]djmbbandie[/STRIKE], Pyrotechnician, Noodle

    Day 2 Vote Count
    Caluin Graye (4) - coju, Malevolent, Ankeli, Noammr, Drixx
    Malevolent (1) - Moar, thefranklin
    coju (9) - Pyrotechnician, Solar Ice, Gwaihir, djmbbandie, kestegs, Moar, Caluin Graye, BipolarChemist, Malevolent

    Day 3 Vote Count

    Malevolent (1) - thefranklin, [STRIKE]Gwaihir[/STRIKE], [STRIKE]Malevolent[/STRIKE]
    Caluin Graye (0) - [STRIKE]Noammr[/STRIKE]
    Drixx (0) - [STRIKE]Drixx[/STRIKE]
    kestegs (0) - [STRIKE]kestegs[/STRIKE]
    Ankeli (0) - [STRIKE]Caluin Graye[/STRIKE]
    Noammr (1) - Noammr
    flubbucket (0) - [STRIKE]flubbucket[/STRIKE]
    djmbbandie (0) - [STRIKE]djmbbandie[/STRIKE]
    Noodle (10) - Gwaihir, Pyrotechnician, Drixx, kestegs, djmbbandie, BipolarChemist, flubbucket, Malevolent, Caluin Graye, Moar
    Moar (0) - [STRIKE]Moar[/STRIKE]
    thefranklin (1) - [STRIKE]Drixx[/STRIKE], Noodle
    BipolarChemist (0) - [STRIKE]BipolarChemist[/STRIKE]

    Day 4 Vote Count
    thefranklin (1) - Drixx, Noammr
    BipolarChemist (0) - Gwaihir
    Drixx (0) - Caluin Graye, Moar, kestegs, thefranklin
    Moar (1) - Drixx
    Noammr (7) - Gwaihir, djmbbandie, Caluin Graye, kestegs, thefranklin, Pyrotechnician, Moar
    Gwaihir (1) - flubbucket

    Day 5 Vote Count
    Drixx (2) - [STRIKE]Caluin Graye[/STRIKE], thefranklin, BipolarChemist
    kestegs (6) - Drixx, flubbucket, Moar, Pyrotechnician, djmbbandie, Caluin Graye
    flubbucket (1) - kestegs

    Day 6 Vote Count
    Drixx (0) - [STRIKE]Moar[/STRIKE], [STRIKE]thefranklin[/STRIKE], [STRIKE]Caluin Graye[/STRIKE],
    Caluin Graye (1) - [STRIKE]Drixx[/STRIKE], flubbucket, [STRIKE]djmbbandie[/STRIKE],
    Pyrotechnician (0)- [STRIKE]flubbucket[/STRIKE],
    thefranklin (1) - BipolarChemist, [STRIKE]djmbbandie[/STRIKE], [STRIKE]Drixx[/STRIKE],
    Moar (0) - [STRIKE]Drixx[/STRIKE],
    BipolarChemist (1) - [STRIKE]Caluin Graye[/STRIKE], [STRIKE]Moar[/STRIKE], thefranklin,
    flubbucket (5) - Moar, Caluin Graye, Drixx, Pyrotechnician, djmbbandie

    Day 7 Vote Count
    Caluin Graye (0) - [STRIKE]Moar[/STRIKE], [STRIKE]Bipolar Chemist[/STRIKE],
    BipolarChemist (1) - [STRIKE]Caluin Graye[/STRIKE], Moar
    djmbbandie (0) - [STRIKE]djmbbandie[/STRIKE],
    Drixx (0) - [STRIKE]Drixx[/STRIKE],
    Moar (3) - Drixx, Bipolar Chemist, Caluin Graye

    Day 8 Vote Count
    BipolarChemist (2) - djmbbandie, Drixx

    [HR][/HR]
    Day 1 Starts.
    Noodle replaces FredOfErik.
    Day 1 Ends. Sathoris is lynched: Forger, Town
    Day 2 Starts. pharphis died.
    Day 2 Ends. coju is lynched: Vanilla, Town
    Day 3 Starts. Bad Ash and Solar Ice died.
    Day 3 Ends. Noodle is lynched: Vanilla, Mafia.
    Ankeli is modkilled. Vanilla. Town.
    Day 4 Starts. Malevolent died.
    Day 4 Ends. Noammr is lynched: Vanilla, Mafia.
    Day 5 Starts. Nobody died.
    Day 5 Ends. kestegs is lynched: Vanilla, Town.
    Day 6 Starts. Gwaihir died.
    Day 6 Ends. flubbucket is lynched: Bumble, Town.
    Day 7 Starts. Pyrotechnician and thefranklin died.
    Day 7 Ends. Moar is lynched: Cliff/Postman, Town.
    Day 8 Starts. Caluin Graye died.
    Day 8 Ends. BipolarChemist is lynched: Vanilla, Mafia. Town wins.
    Last edited: Jun 23, 2013
  5. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    [TABLE="width: 550"]
    Order Player Alignment Bid Role Pick Assigned Role 1 Malevolent town 4//4 Rogue Rogue 2 djmbbandie town 7//19 Prof. Farnsworth Prof. Farnsworth 3 Solar Ice mafia 9//2 Bean Bean 4 pharphis cult 10//10 Fifth Fifth 5 Sathoris town 11//1 Forger Forger 6 coju town 17//20 Fifth Vanilla 7 flubbucket town 2//5 Bumble Bumble 8 Noammr mafia 2//23 Prof. Farnsworth Vanilla 9 Caluin Graye town 3//1 Fifth Vanilla 10 thefranklin town 3//2 Fifth Vanilla 11 Drixx neutral 6//3 Mystery Win Con Rose de Nose 12 Pyrotechnician town 6//5 Parrot Parrot 13 kestegs town 6/13 Rogue Vanilla 14 Moar town 5//8 Cliff Cliff 15 Bad Ash town 5//18 Fifth Vanilla 16 Gwaihir town 5//1 Parrot Vanilla 17 BipolarChemist mafia 5//1 Rogue Vanilla 18 Ankeli town x//x x Vanilla 19 Noodle mafia x//x Bumble Vanilla [/TABLE]

    [HR][/HR]
    N1 Actions
    pharphis (Fifth) recruits BPC [fails because BPC is mafia]
    djmbbandie (Prof. Farnsworth) invents BTAU and gives to Gwaihir
    Pyro (Parrot) mimics djmbbandie with new target(s) of djmbbandie and Noodle
    Pyro (mimicked Prof) invents BTAU and gives to djmbbandie
    Moar (Cliff) did not use the ability
    Solar Ice (Bean) - listens to Mafia Chat post 96
    Malevolent (Rogue) - Track: Drixx Result: Drixx did not visit anyone
    Mafia NK - Bipolar Chemist kills pharphis

    N2 Actions
    djmbbandie (Prof.) invents BTAU and gives to Gwaihir
    djmbbandie (BTAU) swaps djmbbandie and thefranklin
    Pyrotechnician (Parrot) mimics Malevolent (swapped to Noodle) with new targets of Solar Ice and Malevolent (swapped to Noodle)
    Pyro (mimicked mafia NK) kills Solar Ice
    Moar (Cliff) delays actions meant for Caluin Graye
    Gwaihir (BTAU) swaps Malevolent and Noodle
    Malevolent (Rogue) - Watch: Moar Result: Moar was not visited by anyone
    Mafia NK - Noodle kills Bad Ash (with his teeth)

    N3 Actions
    djmbbandie (Prof) invents WIM and gives to Drixx
    Pyrotechnician (Parrot) mimics Malevolent and with new targets of Moar & BPC (swapped to Pyro)
    Pyro (mimicked Rogue) tracks Moar - Result: Moar visits BPC
    Moar (Cliff) delays actions meant for Pyro (swapped to BPC)
    Gwaihir (BTAU) swaps Pyro and BPC
    Malevolent (Rogue) Track: kestegs Result: kestegs did not visit anyone
    Mafia NK: BPC kills Malevolent

    N4 Actions
    djmbbandie (Prof) invents BTAU and gives to Gwaihir
    Pyro mimicks flub and targets flub & BPC
    Moar (Cliff) delays actions meant for Pyro
    Drixx (WIF) blocks kestegs
    no mafia NK

    N5 Actions
    djmbbandie (Prof) invents Doomsday Device
    Pyrotechnician (Parrot) mimics BPC (swapped to Pyro) and targets BPC (swapped to Pyro) and thefranklin
    Pyro (mimicked Parrot) Parrot mimicking Parrot is a special case - nothing happens
    Moar (Cliff) delays actions meant for Pyro (swapped to BPC)
    Gwaihir (BTAU) swaps Pyro and BPC
    Mafia NK: BPC kills Gwaihir

    N6 Actions
    djmbbandie (Prof) uses Doomsday Device on thefranklin
    Pyro (Parrot) mimics thefranklin, targeting thefranklin and BPC
    Moar (Cliff) delays actions meant for Moar
    Mafia NK: not used

    N7 Actions
    djmbbandie (Prof) doesn't invent anything
    Mafia NK: BPC kills CG
    [HR][/HR]
    Dead Thread.
    Mafia QT.
    Cult QT
    Prof. Farnsworth QT
    Cliff (Postman) QT
    Last edited: Jun 23, 2013
  6. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    Send in your role picks. The sooner the better.
    Last edited: May 29, 2013
  7. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    Fair warning to all...

    I plan on starting the game tomorrow whether or not everyone has submitted a pick. Don't tempt fate (or a maniacal mod)!
  8. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    Role PMs are being sent...

    Everyone is getting a quickie role PM right now. It'll be pretty much copy/paste from the Role List. I'll have more detailed role PMs written after I've had some dinner.

    Don't be surprised if you see something like this:

    I’m a slacker and need a co-mod. ThunderCat has graciously offered to co-mod. Because both of us need access to any role actions, decisions and questions, we have set up a QT specifically for this purpose.
    Your QT is here.
  9. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?
    Are we there yet?


    STOP IT!


    The next person to ask that question get's a visit from the spankin hand!

    Noooooo.
    No.
    We'll be good, we promise.
    *sob*
    You're no fun!

    You want fun? Let's play a game...

    [HR][/HR]

    Day 1 has started. It will end on Monday at 5pm EST.

    There are 19 players alive. It takes 10 votes to lynch/lock.


    [HR][/HR]
    I'm looking for a replacement for FredOfErik. If you hurry, you still get to pick a role.
  10. pharphis

    pharphis IncGamers Site Pal

    Joined:
    Aug 1, 2011
    Messages:
    9,848
    Likes Received:
    30
    Trophy Points:
    218
    It looks like we finally started!
  11. Drixx

    Drixx IncGamers Site Pal

    Joined:
    Apr 8, 2006
    Messages:
    3,502
    Likes Received:
    2
    Trophy Points:
    373
    Would it be appropriate to say "wheeeeeeeee!"?
  12. Malevolent

    Malevolent IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 8, 2011
    Messages:
    2,501
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    166
    maybe, or maybe he is just trolling us again.

    So is this normal day start/end time? because if it is i am not going to be around for it on weekdays
  13. Goryani

    Goryani IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 7, 2005
    Messages:
    3,455
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    It's later than normal time. A normal day will start/end about 4 hours ago.
  14. Malevolent

    Malevolent IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 8, 2011
    Messages:
    2,501
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    166
    ok, so it will be around the time i leave for school, hopefully at least 10 mins before, but i will cope
  15. Caluin Graye

    Caluin Graye IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Sep 4, 2005
    Messages:
    2,323
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    121
    Well, I suppose somebody has to be Goryani since Goryani can't be himself this game.

    Some open ended questions for people to ponder:

    1) Which role do you think would be most harmful to mafia in the hands of town? Which role most harmful to town in hands of mafia?

    2) Which role do you least expect to smurfing see in this game? Which role do you hope won't appear in this game, and why?

    3) @ DJM, SI, Pharphis: You picked middle of the pack numbers, but ended up in the top four picks. Do you feel this makes you prime TARGETS when you instead you might have meant to get a safer pick position?
  16. Malevolent

    Malevolent IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Aug 8, 2011
    Messages:
    2,501
    Likes Received:
    1
    Trophy Points:
    166
    1) Quite possibly the Listener, it just depends on if the name of the poster is also revealed, might get a tad confusing considering the high possibility or the barkeep role.

    2) i think the souless role could absolutely wreck all the power roles. The only way to catch him/her would be to judge thier posting/voting. Although if the souless person is targeted and the person who targeted is informed that they are souless, it could just end up being an easy lynch.

    @ gory- i presume that in-depth info on the roles will not be given out?
  17. djmbbandie

    djmbbandie IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Feb 2, 2012
    Messages:
    5,096
    Likes Received:
    14
    Trophy Points:
    124
    To Mafia, the most dangerous would probably be Professor Farnsworth, the items could cause chaos and problems. To town, I'd say the Forger, because that also has a chance to cause chaos for the investigative roles.

    I do. But I had a feeling that day to pick 7, it was like the number was calling out to me...

    Anyway, I'm in the middle of review for finals next week, so this might be my one post today.



    5pm end times are bad for me. I'm either in the middle of dinner or headed to class.
  18. djmbbandie

    djmbbandie IncGamers Member

    Joined:
    Feb 2, 2012
    Messages:
    5,096
    Likes Received:
    14
    Trophy Points:
    124
    And 5pm end times are good for me not bad, I will just be starting to get ready for class, disregard the last sentence.
  19. pharphis

    pharphis IncGamers Site Pal

    Joined:
    Aug 1, 2011
    Messages:
    9,848
    Likes Received:
    30
    Trophy Points:
    218
    1)I need to have another look at the role list.

    2)I really expect to see the smurf role, tbh. I think you probably took it or are keeping the possibility of you having the role open for interpretation. You either have it or are preparing to fake it based on responses imo. I thought a lot about the role before the game started :p

    I'll have to look at your position and think more about the WIFOM of the pick order and smurf pick.

    Can you make a post without the smurf talk before the rest have made their first post?

    3) Well, I intended for a high position, and figured 10/11 would be safe bets (yay sath and I!). Does that make me a prime target? I think it mostly depends on my play today. Leaving 1st bidders up for a few days causes lots of WIFOM as happened a bit last game and we talked about it a bit in the signup thread I think.
  20. Pyrotechnician

    Pyrotechnician IncGamers Site Pal

    Joined:
    Apr 21, 2011
    Messages:
    6,518
    Likes Received:
    31
    Trophy Points:
    169
    But I wanna! I wanna, I wanna, I wanna!!!

Share This Page