Latest Diablo 3 News
DiabloWiki Updates
Page 1 of 2 12 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 13
  1. #1
    IncGamers Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2013
    Location
    usa
    Posts
    1

    Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    At least for anything other than a single target.

    When I do the math on the damage for pvm, whirlwind seems to do way more dps than frenzy, with dual wielding whirlwind getting 12.5 hits a second where the most frenzy can manage is 5 and that's after the time it needs to charge up, which is the main reason it seems to outclass frenzy so much, especially with charms.

    Am I missing something? Maybe you can very rarely get 12.5 hits a second or something else I am missing? Yet frenzy seems to be the more popular option which I don't understand
    Last edited by bobbarb; 14-06-2013 at 19:51.

  2. #2
    IncGamers Member
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    seattle wa
    Posts
    68

    Re: Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    Well i played frenzy for like 5 years before i ever made a ww'er. it was play style for me. i was drawn to the fun and crazy pace of a frenzy barb. hell it was so fast that sometimes you run around monsters when youre trying to kill lol. and before i ever had my first enigma, my frenzy barb helped me get around pretty quick
    as far as ubers, frenzy was easssssy to uber with also. not as fast as a smitr of course. but doable and fun.
    one of the cool thing about frenzy is the chance to cast procs in the game on weapons. you dont get these on ww. but ive made frenzy barbs that are like watching a light show stuff going off every other second. fun stuff.

  3. #3
    IncGamers Member royalairfarce's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2010
    Location
    Belgium
    Posts
    578

    Re: Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    I like Frenzy more then WW.
    WW mana cost is pretty high (undead non leechable), harder to aim, lower damage (per hit: WW28 is 166%, Freny 28 +20 Double swing nets 393%), so u can synergise Frenzy better, higher AR. Take into account that u have to land all those extra hits/sec u produce.

    Frenzy is just more laid back: put it on right click, right-click the ground and let your toon Chase your cursor @ high speed. Any Mob u encounter melts away.

    Try em both I'll say and see what u like best

    (Only played IK WW barb and Grief/Death Fenzy so had not much of a damage comparisson)

  4. #4
    IncGamers Member
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Seattle
    Posts
    370

    Re: Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    Quote Originally Posted by bobbarb View Post
    At least for anything other than a single target.

    When I do the math on the damage for pvm, whirlwind seems to do way more dps than frenzy, with dual wielding whirlwind getting 12.5 hits a second where the most frenzy can manage is 5 and that's after the time it needs to charge up, which is the main reason it seems to outclass frenzy so much, especially with charms.

    Am I missing something? Maybe you can very rarely get 12.5 hits a second or something else I am missing? Yet frenzy seems to be the more popular option which I don't understand
    Try actually playing them instead of doing the math. I've played both and Frenzy is definitely the easier PvM skill. When I use Whirlwind, a lot of the time I'm spinning around, back and forth, over a mob, and only damaging some of them. Often, Whirlwind goes right through a monster without doing any damage, even when the LCS says I have a 95% chance to hit it. It's a powerful skill, but it's also kind of unreliable, mana-intensive, and not nearly as good against bosses. Also, the Frenzy charges tend to last a long time, because I run so fast that I can clear entire areas, running from kill to kill, without my charges expiring.

  5. #5
    IncGamers Member zrk's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Posts
    1,965

    Re: Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    Quote Originally Posted by Namtar View Post
    Try actually playing them instead of doing the math. I've played both and Frenzy is definitely the easier PvM skill. When I use Whirlwind, a lot of the time I'm spinning around, back and forth, over a mob, and only damaging some of them. Often, Whirlwind goes right through a monster without doing any damage, even when the LCS says I have a 95% chance to hit it. It's a powerful skill, but it's also kind of unreliable, mana-intensive, and not nearly as good against bosses. Also, the Frenzy charges tend to last a long time, because I run so fast that I can clear entire areas, running from kill to kill, without my charges expiring.
    WW has less built in ED and AR than frenzy so it improves more than frenzy does from getting better gear.

    Also, when you see a WW baba with a massive poleaxe spin past you while your frenzy guy is running around with his "toy" axes you will learn something :P

  6. #6
    IncGamers Member
    Join Date
    Dec 2006
    Location
    Pittsburgh
    Posts
    1,423

    Re: Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    Because it's awesome.

  7. #7
    IncGamers Member
    Join Date
    May 2012
    Location
    Seattle
    Posts
    370

    Re: Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    Quote Originally Posted by zrk View Post
    WW has less built in ED and AR than frenzy so it improves more than frenzy does from getting better gear.
    By that logic, the basic attack, which has even less bonus ED and AR (because it has none), must be even better.

  8. #8
    IncGamers Member langevi's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jul 2003
    Location
    Sweden
    Posts
    68

    Re: Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    Quote Originally Posted by zrk View Post
    Also, when you see a WW baba with a massive poleaxe spin past you while your frenzy guy is running around with his "toy" axes you will learn something
    see a WW spinning past you doing 0 damage. Why use toyaxes? There is many big swords and good maces that is 1-handed.

  9. #9
    IncGamers Member Archone's Avatar
    Join Date
    Nov 2010
    Location
    Sweden
    Posts
    8,587

    Re: Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    Quote Originally Posted by zrk View Post
    WW has less built in ED and AR than frenzy so it improves more than frenzy does from getting better gear.
    Quote Originally Posted by Namtar View Post
    By that logic, the basic attack, which has even less bonus ED and AR (because it has none), must be even better.
    Exactly!
    I loled hard when I read that!

    Im a fan of WW. But Im not ignorant of that frenzy is an awesome skill.
    You can use a frenzy barb for Ubers for example. WW sucks vs Ubers.

    -A well built frenzy barb can do alot more dmg, and hits alot more with higher AR. Half the hits is made up for more than twice the damage.
    -Benefits from ctc items, like atmas,draculs or last wish.
    -Runs larger areas faster, killspeed isnt really affected.
    -And does better singletarget dmg.


    WW is a safer skill. Due to lots of extra points you can put in survival skills.
    Thats why I love ww, and because its alot cooler ofc!



    Peace and love

  10. #10
    IncGamers Member
    Join Date
    Jan 2008
    Location
    Amazon Basin
    Posts
    1,041

    Re: Why would anyone use frenzy over whirlwind?

    Quote Originally Posted by zrk View Post
    Also, when you see a WW baba with a massive poleaxe spin past you while your frenzy guy is running around with his "toy" axes you will learn something :P
    That appearances can be deceiving?

    The standard Berserker Axes may look dinky but they still have rangeadder 2, the maximum for any one-handed weapon: this gives them range 3-5 versus size 1-3 targets. Whirlwind only searches for targets in a 5 sub-tile or 3 1/3 yard radius, so although with any other attack a rangeadder 4 polearm has range 5-7, with Whirlwind it's restricted to a little less than range 5:


    The vast majority of monsters are size 2-3, so there is no range advantage to equipping the polearm over the axe when attacking size 3 targets, while the axe still covers ~85% of the range of the polearm against size 2 targets.

    Having posted that, with Whirlwind you can potentially attack every 4 frames with one two-handed weapon (6.25 attacks per second) or two one-handed weapons (12.5/s), whereas Frenzy can only attack every 10 frames with two one-handed weapons (5/s).

    Quote Originally Posted by Namtar View Post
    Quote Originally Posted by zrk View Post
    WW has less built in ED and AR than frenzy so it improves more than frenzy does from getting better gear.
    By that logic, the basic attack, which has even less bonus ED and AR (because it has none), must be even better.
    I think he meant the difference between +% Damage and Attack Rating of the two skills becomes less significant as other sources are added. Level 20 Whirlwind may only apply +102% Damage (* 2.02) to level 20 Frenzy's +345% (* 4.45) with level 20 Double Swing's synergy bonus, but once you add a level 20 weapon Mastery (+123%), mercenary supplying level 17 Might (+200%), 200 Strength (+200%) and Fortitude body armor (+300%) the difference is between +946% (* 10.46) and +1,168% (* 12.68), or +1,328% (* 14.28) with level 20 Taunt's synergy bonus: Frenzy only does ~21%, or ~36.5%, more damage per hit at this stage.

    Level 20 Whirlwind may only apply +95% AR (* 1.95) to level 20 Frenzy's +233% (* 3.33), but adding a level 20 weapon mastery (+180%) results in the difference being between +275% (* 3.75) and +413% (* 5.13); +218% from a Demonlimb Unique Tyrant Club's level 23 Enchant charges results in the difference being between +493% (* 5.93%) and +631% (* 7.31)... and ~37% or ~23% more AR doesn't normally translate into an equivalent percentage increase in chance to hit (particularly when chance to hit is already high).

    In that sense, Whirlwind may become better if the difference in damage per hit and chance to hit is reduced to the point where its superior attack rate still allows it to apply more DPS... although this assumes that a target is always within range, and doesn't take into account the time taken travelling between targets.

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •