South Park forum Mafia. Game thread.

[Jcakes]

Noodles conformation of his char, BA's claim and the fact that you forced the real Cop to claim in order to counteract your bogus one thereby outing himself before he got a guilty result on someone and helped us lynch the right person. You say that you are Town now and had a good reason to lie, yet refuse to state your case when caught out, as as well as you possibly wasted a Day on this major distraction for the Town. As I see it, if you are Town like you said (and there is not a shred of evidence to support that) you picked possibly the most damaging claim to make and lie about.

This. I am not sure if anything kegs says will be able to convince me not to vote. I wonder if he is a VI or some other neutral role.

[MartinLong]

Anyways, very suspicious of omg today, but too late to go any more with that.
ML you agreed with with this statement, stating Timmay timmay.
Was it because you found
Malevolent suspicious?
omg suspicious?

timmay timmay
timmay timmay

[Goryani]

Well this isn't exactly going as planned :(

Autti wasn't supposed to claim, I didn't really want to out the doc.

I'm not the cop. I'm not mafia either. I'm town, and I had a good reason to lie.

The whole "I'd lie if I had these specific roles..." schtick assumes a little white lie. A lie that hurts yourself is OK. A lie that hurts the town is NOT. I see a substantial amount of prep work for what appears to be marginal, if not negative utility. That doesn't exactly give credence to a townie that has good reason to lie. You even counterclaimed the player who counterclaimed your now admitted fake claim...

[Laarz]

Been thinking about this, it seems that kegs may be trying to get lynched,why? these come to mind
kegs is the VI, like others have mentioned
kegs is unlynchable, for reasons yet unknown
he maybe able to take some people out when he's lynched

I dont see why he has done this if he truly is town, i'm heading off to bed and will pick this up in the morning.

[Goryani]

Maybe this is just the games I have read, but I seem to remember seeing about 3 total insane cops. Of these, 2 received innocent results on themselves. So in a game here, I am not sure you can even trust a self investigation, so it would be pointless to waste a night on it.

This sounds about right. There should be more than 3 insane cops but maybe you haven't read that far back. Even if insane cops could reliably detect their own sanity, I still think they shouldn't self investigate.

I thought timmay timmay was yes, TIMMAY!!! was no. I would say that Timmay!!! is closer to a no.

According to Malevolent's initial code and Jcakes later recap after adding the not sure part...
Timmay Timmay = agree
TIMMAY!!! = disagree
tim tim timmay? = not sure.

I see all caps as no, all lowercase as not sure, and capital T, lowercase immy to be yes. MartinLong can agree or disagree with either of us to clarify.

Not sure about people who jumped on FOE, that depends a lot on if kegs is actually an insane Officer Barbrady. If so, likely mostly town. If kegs is mafia, I bet some mafia hopped on that train a swell.

Originally I was wondering how mafia would react to an incorrect sane/insane assumption. My guess was that a sane cop mistakenly assuming insane investigations would be met with some quick mafia votes. Mistaken sanity seems to not be an issue anymore, but a mistaken cop claim on a non-mafia player might still be. Unfortunately, I don't see any way to analyze those votes to help with today's vote.

[ThunderCat]

Vote tally has been updated. Day will end in 11 hours and 20 minutes.

[Jcakes]

This sounds about right. There should be more than 3 insane cops but maybe you haven't read that far back. Even if insane cops could reliably detect their own sanity, I still think they shouldn't self investigate.


According to Malevolent's initial code and Jcakes later recap after adding the not sure part...
Timmay Timmay = agree
TIMMAY!!! = disagree
tim tim timmay? = not sure.

I see all caps as no, all lowercase as not sure, and capital T, lowercase immy to be yes. MartinLong can agree or disagree with either of us to clarify.


Originally I was wondering how mafia would react to an incorrect sane/insane assumption. My guess was that a sane cop mistakenly assuming insane investigations would be met with some quick mafia votes. Mistaken sanity seems to not be an issue anymore, but a mistaken cop claim on a non-mafia player might still be. Unfortunately, I don't see any way to analyze those votes to help with today's vote.

timmay timmay = agree (two timmays on the same line)
TIMMAY!!! = disagree

note that sometimes TIMMAY!!! will be in lowercase if that is all he wrote. I.E if his single post was TIMMAY!!! it will look like timmay!!!

[FredOfErik]

I am indeed Granpa Marsh. I've never watched an episode with him but have read his wiki. I've wondered a bit about why I had to quote Stan and not Billy - in the show granpa apparently has alzheimers and can't remember his grandson's name. Other than that I read that he have tried to convince stan to help him commit suicide. I semi-breadcrumbed my role here:

I'm tired of everything.

Vote: kestegs

I've said it all game. Either you are scum or you have played exceptionally bad. Almost so bad that I'm starting to think you might be VI. But I'm more than willing to test it.

If people feel like it I'll be willing to unvote and place the locking vote (if I'm still awake come day end) - just in case he's a bomb or something like that I think town will learn more from my death.

Sorry about the lurking. Busy weekend.

[FredOfErik]

And just for the record he's at lock-1 by my count.

[Ankeli]

I'm not going to vote for kegs, as to me it seems like he's the VI and I don't want him to share in on the victory.

I'll actually keep my vote on FoE, because to me Grandpa Marsh doesn't necessarily seem pro-town, especially given that Chef was the SK.