Roles of Madness. Mafia Thread

[Caluin Graye]

Mafia QT link:
http://www.quicktopic.com/47/H/xpHiJp8wt9e9N

[RlyehExiled]

I really do want to know - what happens if I got role thiefed?

I think I wrote it wouldnt work, I'll check later, but I'm pretty sure because power thief didn't alter alignment (and stealing a 3rd parties role is just unfair anyway) the switch just doesn't happen. Else stuff like 3rd party cops that win if only they are alive, and town aligned SKs that win when all threats to the town are dead. (So the mafia and that 3rd party cop).

[Caluin Graye]

Goryani, I died for you sins, you owe me in-game.

Rlyeh, my role was awful, I hated it, and I'll never forgive you. You shall suffer my wrath the next time I'm mafia.

Bodyguard is a good role. Not as powerful as doctor, but still useful, which in of itself makes it ideal for some games.

You saved a cop, and one of the town's best players, from two different night kills. How can you consider that to be awful?

[Gwaihir]

I think I wrote it wouldnt work, I'll check later, but I'm pretty sure because power thief didn't alter alignment (and stealing a 3rd parties role is just unfair anyway) the switch just doesn't happen. Else stuff like 3rd party cops that win if only they are alive, and town aligned SKs that win when all threats to the town are dead. (So the mafia and that 3rd party cop).

Probably more fair, but it might have been amusing to have my power held hostage against me to make sure I played nice with the town. And by amusing, more of an after the fact amusing as opposed to in game amusing.

[Gwaihir]

Also, I am still amazed I did not get lynched for my claim. I was completely honest, and tried to be as clear as possible, but man it was shady. I was so worried that my first ward to FoE got bussed or FoE was mafia and he would not claim having it, or many other possibilities that would immediately get me lynched.

[Bad Ash]

Thanks for hosting! Defintely unbalanced, but it happens to all of us. Fun concept of the game and I think the dream concept is one that should be pushed to be made better because it could be pretty epic!

[coju]

Had a blast! Really wish the dream: crimson and rain (or w//e) would have been played. That's pretty awesome.

Fun game. I enjoyed it. Loved the dream idea.

Town being op/Mafia being u.p.? Nahh, town won, i'm town, I made it to the end: perfecto! Mwah!

But, in all honestly, I don't know enough about balance to successfully analyze that. It was fun. And unbalanced games are like life: not fair. Which makes them/it fun

[Jcakes]

Had a blast! Really wish the dream: crimson and rain (or w//e) would have been played. That's pretty awesome.

Fun game. I enjoyed it. Loved the dream idea.

Town being op/Mafia being u.p.? Nahh, town won, i'm town, I made it to the end: perfecto! Mwah!

But, in all honestly, I don't know enough about balance to successfully analyze that. It was fun. And unbalanced games are like life: not fair. Which makes them/it fun

I think Coju should get an award for being a proven cop that had be found innocent and yet townies still wanted to lynch him

[coju]

I think Coju should get an award for being a proven cop that had be found innocent and yet townies still wanted to lynch him

Rolf! Thanks! Even when I nearly purely lurk, try and be completely opposite from previous games... Scummy is as scummy does.

[kestegs]

Coju: I was pretty convinced you might actually be scum, even though you weren't on my team

Like I said, unbalanced, but still fun. I felt like I was instrumental in sk's lynch and then jcakes demise, which made me happy.

And I didn't claim doc on death, I was giving my results on LoZ it was rather funny that my role didn't get revealed though.