Wow walls of text, thanks to Mike for putting it in a single post.
If you're going to try and give lessons about grammar, you could at least spell receive properly If you want to believe "You've problems" is all fine and dandy so be it, but to say the least its awkward.
I like the bit about making poison damage useless - even reduced, its still doing damage, and unless you're healing yourself beyond replenish life on your gear, it still works toward taking your opponent to 0 - Not to mention that poison length reduction isn't found on your typical setups be default. The same could be said about the integer damage reduction.
This thread turned into more of a pissing contest than anything, but it's basically been people doubting the possibilities for the sin and experienced sins saying otherwise.
Considering all the little things the pvp gurus have taught me, I've learned to consider the improbable. Afterall, I would have never even thought a trap was WoF had any purpose in PVP between the lack of damage and fire resists + absorb.
But we all know what happens when people "discuss" pvp.